Birkin vs. MetaBirkin, dab tsi ib rooj plaub mus sim hnub no yuav txhais tau rau yav tom ntej ntawm Web3

Nyob rau hauv ib rooj plaub npaj xa ripples thoob plaws NFT toj roob hauv pes, khoom kim heev khoom tsim Hermès tab tom foob tus kws kos duab Mason Rothschild dhau 100-ib NFT sau nws hais tias ua txhaum nws cov cim lag luam ntawm lub hnab Birkin iconic.

Thaum Lub Kaum Ob Hlis 2021, Rothschild tau muab 100-ib tsab NFT sau rau OpenSea, tso tawm "MetaBirkins" sau hauv qhov nws hais tias:

"Ib qho khoom plig rau Herm[e]'s 'lub hnab nto moo tshaj plaws, Birkin, yog ib qho ntawm cov khoom siv tshwj xeeb tshaj plaws, zoo tsim khoom kim heev. Nws daim ntawv teev npe tsis txaus ntseeg, hem tus nqi cim npe, thiab qhov tsis txaus siab heev tau ua rau nws lub hnab ntim khoom plig 'dawb huv' uas ua ob npaug raws li kev nqis peev lossis khw muag khoom muaj nqis.'

Rothschild, uas kuj piav txog nws tus kheej li "tus tsim digital" thiab "web3cowboy", muag 100 tsab ntawm NFT rau ntau dua $ 1,000,000 hauv cov txiaj ntsig, suav nrog ib tsab muag rau 100 ETH.

Tsis ntev tom qab ntawd, thaum Lub Ib Hlis 2022, Hermès tau xa tsab ntawv tso tseg thiab tso tseg rau ob qho tib si Rothschild thiab OpenSea, ua rau tom kawg tshem tawm NFT sau los ntawm nws lub khw. 

Rothschild tom qab ntawd teb los ntawm kev muag NFTs ntawm lwm lub platform thiab sau npe rau www.MetaBirkins.com domain nrog kev lees paub:

"Peb tsis koom nrog, koom nrog, tso cai, pom zoo los ntawm, lossis hauv ib txoj hauv kev txuas nrog HERMES, lossis ib qho ntawm nws cov koom tes lossis cov koom nrog. Lub vev xaib HERMES tuaj yeem pom ntawm www.Hermes.com. "

Rothschild tab tom sib cav tias nws NFTs yuav tsum raug suav tias yog thawj cov duab kos, tsis zoo li Andy Warhol's silkscreens ntawm Campbell cov kua zaub kaus poom, uas poob rau hauv Thawj Hloov Kho, tiv thaiv tib neeg txoj cai rau kev ywj pheej ntawm kev hais lus thiab kev kos duab. 

Nyob rau hauv lub tsev hais plaub ua ntaub ntawv los ntawm Rothchild tus kws lij choj coj mus rau qhov kev sim, lawv hais txog ib rooj plaub 1989, Rogers v. Grimaldi, uas tiv thaiv los ntawm kev ua txhaum kev lav phib xaub cov haujlwm uas yog ob qho kev qhia kos duab thiab tsis qhia meej meej rau cov neeg siv khoom. Tus thawj tswj hwm lub tsev hais plaub txiav txim Rakoff pom zoo, hais tias thaum ntawd Rogers thov, cov lus nug ua pov thawj rau dab tsi yog cov khoom lag luam digital piv rau dab tsi yog digital artwork tsis tau tsim. 

Cov ntaub ntawv no yuav ua rau muaj qhov tseem ceeb ua ntej hauv Web3 qhov chaw, uas cov metaverses virtual tau nce zuj zus nrog cov khoom lag luam virtual, nrog rau kev kos duab. 

Cov kws paub txog kev cai lij choj hais ntxiv tias rooj plaub yuav tsim ib qho tseem ceeb ua ntej rau kev txhais cov cim lag luam thoob plaws Web3 qhov chaw.

"[Cov ntaub ntawv Birkin] yuav muab cov lus qhia ntxiv rau peb yuav ua li cas nrog NFTs."

Thomas Brooke, kws lij choj ntawm Holland & Knight, hais Cov phab ntsa Street Journal. Nws ntxivL

"Nrog ib qho kev siv thev naus laus zis tshiab, cov tsev hais plaub feem ntau yuav tsum tau siv txoj cai lij choj uas twb muaj lawm thiab txheeb xyuas qhov ua haujlwm."

Hermès tab tom thov rau lub tsev hais plaub kom muaj Rothschild tso tseg thiab tso tseg los ntawm txhua yam dej num hais txog MetaBirkin NFT, suav nrog kev tso npe rau MetaBirkins.com lub npe thiab forfeiting kev puas tsuaj nrog rau cov txiaj ntsig los ntawm kev muag cov cuab tam digital - uas yog ntau tshaj $ 1,000,000. 

Nws tsis yog thawj zaug uas muaj feem cuam tshuam txog cov cai ntawm kev txawj ntse thiab NFTs tau hnov ​​​​los ntawm US tsev hais plaub. Nike tam sim no foob StockX, lub khau ntaub rov muag dua platform uas sib koom ua ke NFTs txuas rau cov khau lub cev nws rov muag, rau kev sib koom ua ke ntawm lub cim lub cim rau hauv nws cov khoom muaj nqis uas tsis yog fungible. 

StockX sib cav tias nws siv NFTs raws li txoj hauv kev nrawm dua rau cov tswv cuab vet nrog cov neeg muag khoom tab tom nrhiav rau khau khiab tsis muaj lub nra ntawm kev xa khoom tiag tiag. 

Hermes International v. Rothschild tau teem sijhawm pib lub Ib Hlis 30 nyob rau hauv Southern District of New York.

Tau qhov twg los: https://cryptoslate.com/birkin-vs-metabirkin-what-one-case-heading-to-trial-today-may-mean-for-the-future-of-web3/