cov "Kev ua tau zoo ntawm kev lag luam xav tau qhov zoo dua li qhov tsim nyog rau kev xeem dhau." - Ludwig von Mises
Tus kws sau ntawv txoj cai thiab Duke Law School grad George Leef tau qhia kuv ib zaj dab neeg ntev dhau los txog ib tug phooj ywg uas kawm tiav hauv Harvard Law School, thiab leej twg yog tus khub qib ntawm lub tuam txhab kev cai lij choj hauv New York. Leef nug tus kws lij choj tseem ceeb uas nws yuav ntiav yog tias muab kev xaiv ntawm kaum tsib Harvard Law grads, thiab 15 tus neeg uas tau txais kev lees paub rau Harvard Law, tsuas yog ua kom tsis txhob muaj lub sijhawm. Cov lus teb nws tau txais yog tias nws yuav tsis muaj teeb meem nws ntiav leej twg. Tias tag nrho 30 tau txais tsab ntawv lees paub rog yog qhov kev sib txawv uas tseem ceeb rau nws.
Nyob ib ncig ntawm lub sij hawm uas Leef qhia kuv zaj dab neeg saum toj no, tus Phab ntsa Street Journal tso tawm nws qhov qeb duas ntawm cov tsev kawm tiav qib siab hauv Asmeskas kev lag luam. Lub Tsev Kawm Ntawv Qib Siab Michigan Ross Tsev Kawm Ntawv Kev Lag Luam tau nyob qib # 1.
Qhov twg nws tau nthuav, comical, los yog ob qho tib si yog tus lej ntawm Journal Cov neeg sau xov xwm raug xa mus rau zaj dab neeg qeb duas tsuas yog rau ib lossis ntau tus ntawm lawv los tiv tauj cov tswv haujlwm paub tias ntiav Ross grads. Cov tswv ntiav tau nug tias vim li cas U ntawm M lub tsev kawm ua lag luam tsim cov neeg ua haujlwm muaj peev xwm, tsuas yog rau cov tswv lag luam los hais lus txog qhov Ross cov ntaub ntawv kawm tseem ceeb zoo li "yav tom ntej", "kev xav hauv zej zog," "kev daws teeb meem" cov neeg ua haujlwm. Auj, yog li ntawd nws yog #1….
Nyeem txog lub tsev kawm ntawv "zoo tshaj" Asmeskas kev lag luam, nws nyuaj rau tsis txhob tu siab rau cov neeg sau xov xwm tau muab rau ib zaj dab neeg uas tsis txaus ntseeg kiag li. Yog tias tsis muaj qhov tsis lees paub qhov zoo ntawm tsev kawm qib siab lossis kawm tiav tsev kawm ntawv ib ntus, nws nyuaj rau kev xav txog qhov uas tau kawm hauv chav kawm txhais mus rau lub ntiaj teb dav dua. Ntau qhov tseeb, yam qhia tsis muaj teeb meem ntau.
Xav txog John D. Rockefeller, uas yog tus txiv neej nplua nuj tshaj plaws uas tau ua neej nyob. Ntawm lwm yam nws cov nyiaj txiag tsim lub Tsev Kawm Ntawv Qib Siab Chicago, nrog rau kev nce qib tseem ceeb hauv kev kho mob. Tab sis Rockefeller tsis tshua mus kawm lag luam. Tsis yog Bill Gates, lossis Steve Jobs lig. Thaum anecdote qhia peb tsawg heev, cov npe uas tau hais yav dhau los yog ib qho kev ceeb toom tias cov neeg lag luam feem ntau yug los tsis yog kev qhia.
FedEx
Lub neej yav tom ntej ntawm kev lag luam yog ntau dua li opaque. Qhov no txhais tau tias yav tom ntej ntawm kev ua haujlwm yog qhov nyuaj heev rau kev nkag siab hauv lub tebchaws zoo li Tebchaws Meskas Precisely vim tias cov neeg ua lag luam zoo li Smith, Gates, Cov Haujlwm thiab Rockefeller tau hloov pauv tsis tu ncua peb ua li cas thiab peb xav tau li cas, tsis muaj txoj hauv kev tiag tiag rau cov kws qhia ntawv los npaj. peb rau tag kis. Tiag tiag, lawv yuav qhia li cas rau peb hauv qhov pom ntawm cov neeg ua lag luam hloov pauv cov ntsiab lus ntawm kev lag luam li cas?
Lo lus teb rau lo lus nug saum toj no tsis thuam cov xibfwb, tsev kawm qib siab, lossis tsev kawm tiav. Nyob rau tib lub sijhawm, nws yog qhov lees paub tias cov tsev kawm qib siab, tsev kawm qib siab thiab cov tsev kawm tiav qib siab tau txhawb nqa lawv cov tub ntxhais kawm nrog cov ntaub ntawv hnub tim. Peb paub qhov no vim tias tam sim no hauv kev lag luam yog los ntawm kev txhais yav dhau los. Muab lwm txoj hauv kev, cov khoom lag luam thiab cov kev pabcuam zoo tshaj plaws uas zoo li sawv cev ntawm cov khoom thiab cov kev pabcuam yuav sai sai txaus yuav ua rau tsis muaj hnub kawg. Txawm li cas los peb cia siab tias kev kawm yuav npaj peb rau dab tsi tom ntej? Puas yog Rockefeller tau kawm roj av engineering hauv nws lub xyoo ntawm Chancellor University? Puas yog cov kwv tij Wright coj aerodynamics thaum lawv mus kawm ntawv qib siab? Oh tos, lawv tsis mus kawm ntawv qib siab. Qhov twg yog loj dua taw tes.
Tseem ceeb tshaj, cia siab tias nws yog lub ntsiab lus thaum sim nkag siab lub ntsiab lus ntawm kev kawm qib siab thiab kawm tiav qib siab. Nws yog vim li cas "xov xwm" thaum lub hwj chim-uas-yog ntawm Yale Law School tau tawm ntawm Xov Xwm Asmeskas & Tshaj Tawm Ntiaj Teb Kev qeb duas vim yog "txoj kev tsis zoo," tab sis nws muaj tseeb dua hais tias Yale yeej tsis xav tau cov qeb duas li no. Nws tsis yog nws tsis yog vim Yale nyob rau lossis nyob ze rau saum toj kawg nkaus rau qhov taw qhia nkaus xwb uas tseem ceeb: nyuaj rau kev nkag. Yale nyuaj rau nkag mus. Kawg ntawm zaj dab neeg.
Yale yog thawj lub tsev kawm ntawv txoj cai lij choj rau tib lub laj thawj uas Harvard tuaj yeem thov raws li lub tsev kawm ua lag luam tseem ceeb. Ob leeg yog incredibly nyuaj mus rau hauv. Thaum cov qeb duas thiab cov txheej txheem tuaj yeem tshawb pom txhua yam kev ntsuas, suav nrog U ntawm M ua lub tsev kawm ua lag luam # 1, qhov tseeb yooj yim yog tus neeg sib tw Harvard MBA yuav muaj kev nkag tau ntau dua rau cov tswv haujlwm zoo tshaj plaws, thiab qhov no yuav muaj tseeb txawm tias Harvard tsis yog. 'tsis ranked txhua.
Dab tsi ua rau nws cov neeg tseem ceeb yog qhov ntau ntawm lub ntiaj teb kev lag luam xav tau Harvard MBA dua li lawv ua MBAs tau txais los ntawm lwm lub tsev kawm ntawv. Qhov tseeb ntawm Harvard yog qhov tseeb rau Yale Txoj Cai. Cov neeg ntse heev thiab ua tiav heev mus rau ntawd. Hauv lwm lo lus, lawv twb ntse thaum lawv tuaj txog hauv tsev kawm ntawv. Qhov no yog dab tsi Tebchaws Asmeskas Tej zaum tsis paub, thiab tias Yale thiab Harvard tsis nyiam lees.
Tau qhov twg los: https://www.forbes.com/sites/johntamny/2022/12/04/yale-law-school-drops-out-of-a-ranking-system-that-it-never-needed/