Cov 'Nplhaib Ntawm Lub Hwj Chim' Cov Neeg ntxub ntxaug tsis raug, Tolkien's Galadriel yeej ib txwm yog tub rog

Ib tug weirdest kev sib cav kom tawm (tawm ntawm ntau) txog Amazon's Tus Tswv ntawm Rings: Lub Nplhaib ntawm Lub Hwj Chim yog qhov tshiab ntawm Galadriel, uas tau piav qhia raws li ib tug tub rog tub rog uas tua Sauron mus rau qhov kawg ntawm lub ntiaj teb.

Lub tswv yim Tolkien fanboy yog tias qhov no tsis yog qhov nws yuav tsum ua li cas, thiab lawv tsis nyiam qhov nws txawv ntawm qhov zoo nkauj, qee zaus tawg sorceress version ntawm Jackson trilogy.

Qhov teeb meem? Tolkien fanboys tau pom meej tsis tau nyeem txaus Tolkien.

Ntxiv rau qhov tseeb tias Galadriel muaj hnub nyoog ntau txhiab xyoo thiab nyob rau hauv lub xyoo txhiab, tej zaum yuav khaws rab ntaj ib ntus, muaj cov nqe lus tshwj xeeb uas piav qhia txog nws kev sib ntaus sib tua thoob plaws ntau ntawm Tolkien txoj haujlwm.

Redditor Spyson summed li ib tug slew ntawm reference rau qhov no zoo heev:

Xwm ntawm Middle-Earth: “”Tus account ntawm Galadriel sib cav nrog cov tub ntawm Fëanor ntawm lub hnab ntawm Alqualondë. Yuav ua li cas nws tau tawm tsam ”…

Unfinished Tales: “nws… fought heroically”

Morgoth's Nplhaib: "Marginal ceeb toom tawm tsam cov nqe lus piav qhia txog kev koom tes ntawm tus tswv tsev thib ob hauv kev sib ntaus: 'Finrod thiab Galadriel (nws tus txiv yog ntawm Teleri) tau tawm tsam Feanor hauv kev tiv thaiv ntawm Alqualonde."

Cov neeg ntawm Middle-Earth: “Txawm tias tom qab kev ua phem tsis zoo rau Teleri thiab kev tsim txom ntawm lawv lub nkoj, txawm hais tias nws tau tawm tsam hnyav rau Feanor tiv thaiv nws niam cov kwv tij, nws tsis tig rov qab. Nws kev khav theeb tsis kam rov qab los, ib tug swb rau kev zam txim; tiam sis tam sim no nws tau kub hnyiab nrog kev xav ua raws Feanor nrog nws txoj kev npau taws mus rau txhua thaj av uas nws yuav tuaj, thiab cuam tshuam nws txhua txoj hauv kev uas nws ua tau. "

Yog tias muaj ib tus cwj pwm los sim piav qhia tias yog "Mary Sue," nrog cov txuj ci uas tsis tau txais txiaj ntsig, nws tsis yog ntau txhiab xyoo elf uas Tolkien pheej hais tias yog ib tus neeg muaj zog tshaj plaws thiab muaj zog tshaj plaws hauv nws lub luag haujlwm tag nrho. Nws tau piav qhia tias yog "Amazonian" ntawm ib qho, uas yog qhov tseeb version peb tau pom hauv qhov yeeb yam: ""[Galadriel] yog Amazon txoj cai thiab khi nws cov plaub hau ua lub kaus mom thaum koom nrog kev ncaws pob, "Tolkien tsab ntawv 348.

Tau kawg qhov no tsuas yog ... ruam heev. Nws yog kev sib xyaw ua ke ntawm misogyny, qhov twg nws yog koj cov neeg coob coob ntawm dudes uas xav tias ib tug poj niam raug coj los ua ib tug tub rog phem yog "sawv," thiab tom qab ntawd tsawg kawg qee qhov ntawm qhov kawg ntawm qhov kev xav uas lawv xav tias nws yog kev ntxeev siab ntawm rab ntaj- tsawg dua Jackson trilogy Galadriel thiab Tolkien txoj haujlwm ua kom nws ua tub rog hnyav, uas peb tuaj yeem pom, tsuas yog tsis muaj tseeb kiag li. Thaum ntxov peb tau dhau los no qhov zoo dua, tab sis kuv tsis pom qhov ntawd tshwm sim sai sai, tsis muaj pes tsawg phau ntawv peb tuaj yeem hais rau tib neeg.

Ua raws li kuv rau Twitter, YouTube, Facebook thiab Instagram. Sau npe yuav ua rau kuv cov ntsiab lus pub dawb txhua lub hlis puag ncig-tsab ntawv xov xwm, Vajtswv Yob.

Mus nqa kuv cov ntawv sau dab neeg sci-fi Herokiller koob thiab Lub Nees Nruab Nrab Trilogy.