Scott Rolen raug xaiv los rau Baseball Hall Of Fame, Cov neeg xaiv tsa dua tso nqaij rau ntawm pob txha

Lub koom haum Baseball Writers' Association of America (BBWAA) tau rov ua tiav nws lub luag haujlwm pov npav txhua xyoo ntawm Hall of Fame ...

Kuv xav tias zoo dua ob xyoos dhau los, thaum lawv xaiv tsis muaj leej twg, thiab nws kuj zoo dua lub caij kawg thaum lawv xaiv tsuas yog David Ortiz, tus neeg ua si tsawg dua li ntau lwm tus ntawm daim ntawv xaiv tsa.

Los yog tej zaum nws tsis yog qhov txiaj ntsig zoo dua tom qab tag nrho. Qhov no tsis muaj dab tsi ua nrog Rolen, tus tsim nyog Hall of Famer txhua txoj kev koj hlais nws. Nws yog ib tus neeg ua si zoo tshaj plaws ntawm ob txoj kev, yog ib tus zoo tshaj plaws kub ces kaum tiv thaiv puas tau thiab ntshai lub zog hitter (.490 SLG, 517 2B, 316 HR). Detractors yuav nco ntsoov nws tus lej suav zoo tib yam thiab tsis muaj kev ruaj ntseg, tab sis nws tshem tawm Hall of Fame bar yooj yim. Cov txiv neej nrog 70.1 txoj haujlwm bWAR muaj nyob hauv Hall.

Tab sis muaj dua tsis muaj kev zam txim rau tsis cheb ntau cov tswv cuab tsim nyog rau hauv Hall lub sijhawm no. Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens thiab Curt Schilling tau tag nrho tawm ntawm daim ntawv xaiv tsa xyoo no, tsuas yog rov qab hla dhau ntawm Kev Xaiv Tsa Lub Sijhawm uas tau xaiv tsa Fred McGriff tsis muaj zog heev. Kuv tsis tau txais dab tsi tawm tsam Kev Ua Phem Aub, tab sis nws tsuas yog tsis nyob hauv tib pab koomtes li cov players. Tab sis kuv digress.

Xyoo tas los, BBWAA cov tswv cuab tau pov npav rau qhov nruab nrab ntawm 7.11 tus neeg ua si hauv ib daim ntawv xaiv tsa, feem ntau txij li lawv tau teev npe 8.01 tus neeg ua si hauv ib daim ntawv pov npav rov qab rau xyoo 2019. Tam sim no lawv yuav tsum tau siv ntau dua li ntawm kwv yees li 30% tsis siv lub peev xwm xaiv tsa - los ntawm kuv suav, muaj txog 12 tus neeg ua si tsim nyog ntawm kev xaiv tsa xyoo tas los.

Xyoo no, kuv xav tias muaj tsawg dua, hais cuaj lub npe tsim nyog ntawm daim ntawv xaiv tsa. Kuv yuav tau pov npav rau Rolen, Todd Helton (tsuas yog plam nrog 72.2%), Andruw Jones (58.1%), Gary Sheffield (55.0%), Carlos Beltran (46.5%), Jeff Kent (46.5% hauv nws lub xyoo kawg ntawm kev tsim nyog) , Alex Rodriguez (37.5%), Manny Ramirez (33.2%) thiab Bobby Abreu (15.4%). Kuv tsis yog Billy Wagner (68.1%), Kuv paub tseeb tias koj muaj ntau tus tawm ntawm Abreu. Vive le txawv.

Cov neeg pov npav Hall tau txiav txim siab ua dab tsi? Txhawm rau thim rov qab mus rau qis dua 2021 tus lej pov npav rau ib daim ntawv xaiv tsa (5.90). Tsuas yog 5.86 tus neeg pov npav xaiv tsa lub sijhawm no nyob ib puag ncig, qhov qis tshaj txij li xyoo 2012?

Yog li nrog rau feem ntau ntawm cov pos hniav steroid era tawm ntawm daim ntawv xaiv tsa, cov neeg xaiv tsa tsis tau siv qhov zoo ntawm qhov xwm txheej thiab cheb qee tus neeg tsim nyog rau hauv Hall.

Tab sis peb yuav tsum xav tsis thoob? Cov kws sau ntawv 'ham-handed tuav ntawm lub hwj chim-o thaum ntxov 2000s yuav tsum tsis txhob glossed. Kuv tsis muaj teeb meem kiag li khaws cov players uas siv lossis xav tias siv cov tshuaj steroids ua rau lawv cov lej Hall-tsim nyog. McGwire? Tawm. Sosa? Tawm. Palmeiro, hu nyuaj, tab sis tawm.

Tab sis Bonds, Clemens, A-Rod, Manny Ramirez? Koj dag kuv, puas yog?

Bonds thiab Clemens yog nyob rau hauv cov npe luv luv ntawm cov players loj tshaj plaws uas kuv tau pom dua. Lub Hall tsis muaj lawv tsis muaj kev cai lij choj. A-Rod tsis yog nyob ntawm lawv qib, tab sis nws nyob ze. Manny yog me ntsis los ze zog, tab sis nws yog ib tug ntawm cov zoo tshaj plaws ntuj hitters kuv puas tau pom. Kuv thawj zaug pom nws ua si thaum hluas hauv High-A Carolina League, thiab tsis yog tus txiv neej steroid. Nws yog qhov kev ua txhaum tag nrho lawm, nrog qhov tsis txaus ntseeg txhua lub zog uas ntseeg nws qhov siab.

Tab sis BBWAA thiab Pawg Neeg Saib Xyuas Tub Rog ntau yuav hais ntxiv rau peb tias cov txiv neej no thiab Schilling (uas lawv txoj kev nom kev tswv lawv tsis nyiam) tsis yog, thiab Harold Baines, Jack Morris, Jim Rice, Andre Dawson, Bruce Sutter, Lee Smith thiab McGriff ua li cas? Pawg Neeg Saib Xyuas Era yuav luag muab Dale Murphy nrog rau McGriff, ua ntej ntawm Bonds, Clemens thiab Schilling. Ib zaug ntxiv, tus txiv neej zoo, tab sis tsis muaj kev sib piv.

Yog lawm, qhov sib xyaw ntawm BBWAA yog nyob rau hauv nruab nrab ntawm kev hloov pauv loj, thiab kuv ntseeg tias txhua yam nyob rau theem pib ntawm kev ua tau zoo dua. Feem ntau ntawm cov steroid era lub hnab ntim tau poob rau hauv lawv cov ncej puab, thiab tsis ntev nws tag nrho yuav nyob rau hauv tes ntawm Pawg Neeg Saib Xyuas Tub Rog, uas tsis tau tshoov siab rau leej twg nrog lawv txoj haujlwm rau hnub tim. Kuv ntseeg hais tias cov "txoj cai" cov neeg ua si ntawm yav dhau los thiab tam sim no yuav raug muab tso rau hauv Hall. Xyoo tom ntej, Adrian Beltre, Chase Utley thiab Joe Mauer koom nrog kev xaiv tsa. Beltre yuav tsum yog ib qho yooj yim Ib Xyoo hu, koom nrog Wagner, Helton thiab cia siab tias Sheffield hauv nws lub xyoo kawg ntawm kev tsim nyog. Jones thiab Beltran yuav tsum tau txais hauv xyoo tom ntej, nrog rau Ichiro Suzuki, uas nrog rau CC Sabatia yuav tshwm sim hauv daim ntawv xaiv tsa thawj zaug hauv 2025.

Tab sis kuv vam tias qhov kev puas tsuaj tseem tsis tau ua tiav. Txoj hauj lwm ntawm Hall of Fame cov neeg pov npav yog VOTE PLAYERS INTO HALL OF FAME. Muaj ntau lwm tus neeg tsim nyog tau txais txiaj ntsig (Lou Whitaker, leej twg?) uas tsis muaj kev sib cav txog txhua yam hauv lawv keeb kwm yav dhau. Cov txheej txheem tam sim no ntawm cov kws sau ntawv dhau los ua rau lawv mob taub hau rau Pawg Neeg Ua Haujlwm qub tub rog, uas tom qab ntawd …… xaiv tus neeg tsim nyog tsawg kawg nkaus ntawm lawv daim ntawv xaiv tsa hauv Hall tsuas yog yuav tsum xaus. Qhov no tsis yog Frankie Frisch tau txais tag nrho nws cov phooj ywg rau hauv Hall, tab sis nws tau los ze.