Bill Maher thov 'Fat Celebration' tshwm sim hauv Asmeskas, Oversimplifies Obesity Kab Mob

Nws yog qhov txaj muag uas Bill Maher tau hais txog kev rog rog. Rov qab rau xyoo 2019, Maher tau hais kom tib neeg "kev txaj muag rog" ntxiv rau nws HBO qhia "Lub Sijhawm Nrog Bill Maher." Qhov no yog zoo li hais kom neeg mus thab lwm tus ntxiv, raws li kuv tau them rau Forbes. Tam sim no, hauv qhov kawg ntawm nws qhov yeeb yam, Maher yws tias Asmeskas tau "tawm ntawm kev lees txais rog rau kev ua koob tsheej rog." Maher tau hais ntxiv tias "Muaj ib qho kev cuam tshuam tshwm sim hauv Asmeskas hnub no nrog kev sau ntawv tshiab kom haum rau lub tswv yim lossis tsuas yog ua kom haum qhov koj xav kom muaj tseeb," raws li koj tuaj yeem pom hauv qab tweet los ntawm Maher thiab cov vis dis aus nrog:

Tsuas yog kom meej, Maher tsis yog tus kws tshawb fawb. Nws kuj tsis tau nthuav tawm cov kev tshawb fawb txog kev tshawb fawb tiag tiag thaum nws ntu los yog coj cov kws tshawb fawb tiag tiag thiab cov kws tshaj lij ntawm cov ncauj lus mus rau qhov yeeb yam no. Yog li, hmmm, puas yog nws nthuav tawm cov kev tshawb fawb tiag tiag lossis nws lub tswv yim lossis qhov nws xav kom muaj tseeb?

Maher tau hais ntxiv tias, “Yuav saib koj tus kheej tso tseg ua qhov kev khav theeb? Peb tau sim ua kom haum thiab noj qab nyob zoo, thiab zej zog qhuas cov neeg ua tiav. Tam sim no lo lus 'lub cev zoo' yog siv los txhais hais tias, 'Kuv zoo tag nrho txoj kev kuv yog vim kuv yog kuv.'” Umm, uas hais tias lub cev zoo yuav tsum yog hais txog hais tias, "Kuv zoo tag nrho li kuv. puas yog vim kuv yog kuv?” Txawm hais tias qee tus neeg yuav tau twist cov lus ntawd, cov kws kho mob tiag tiag uas yog cov kws tshaj lij hauv cheeb tsam tsis tau hais tias leej twg yuav tsum ntseeg tias lawv zoo tag nrho. Lub neej yog hais txog tas li sim txhim kho. Nws tsis zoo li cov kws kho mob hais rau cov neeg mob, "Koj zoo tag nrho, tsis txhob ua dab tsi," lossis cov ntawv sau xov xwm tshawb fawb tau hais tias, "Txhua tus neeg zoo tag nrho. Qhov kawg.” Txawm hais tias koj lub cev hnyav npaum li cas (BMI), koj txoj kev ua neej tam sim no, lossis koj qhov kev noj qab haus huv zoo li cas, koj ib txwm muaj chaw los txhim kho.

Hloov chaw, lub cev zoo yog hais txog kev nkag siab tias ib qho loj lossis ib qho duab tsis haum rau txhua qhov. Yog tias, piv txwv li, txhua tus yuav tsum zoo li Lebron James, ces Maher yuav muaj ntau txoj haujlwm ua. Hloov chaw, lub cev zoo yog hais txog kev nkag siab tias tus neeg muab khoom tuaj yeem ua tau txhua yam zoo, xws li noj qab haus huv thiab tawm dag zog ntau, tab sis tseem tsis tau muaj lub cev zoo ib yam li tus neeg uas tuaj yeem noj txhua tus dev kub thiab pizza noj zaub mov tseem zoo li qub. Groot los ntawm Saib xyuas ntawm cov Galaxy.

Yog li ntawd, thaum Maher txuas ntxiv nrog "'Kev noj qab haus huv ntawm qhov hnyav' yog ib qho kev dag tsis yooj yim uas tib neeg qhia lawv tus kheej kom lawv tuaj yeem mus thiab noj txhua yam uas lawv xav tau," nws tsis tau qhia meej tias kab lus tiag tiag thiab txhais tau li cas. Ua ntej tshaj plaws, lub sij hawm tsim kho ntau dua yog Kev Noj Qab Haus Huv ntawm Txhua Qhov Loj (HAES). Thiab qhov no tsis tau txhais hais tias koj tuaj yeem noj txhua yam koj xav tau thiab tsis tawm dag zog thiab ntxiv qhov hnyav ntxiv uas tsis muaj qhov tshwm sim. Hloov chaw, nws txhais tau hais tias lub cev loj (lossis qhov hnyav) tsuas yog ib qho kev ntsuas uas ib leeg yuav tsis cuam tshuam rau tib neeg txoj kev noj qab haus huv. Tsis tas li ntawd, ib tug neeg uas tsuas yog tawv nqaij thiab pob txha thiab noj tsis muaj dab tsi tab sis pleev xim rau txhua hnub yuav suav tias yog qhov noj qab haus huv tshaj plaws.

Tom qab ntawd thaum nws hais lus phem, Maher tau hais tias, “Lub sijhawm qee lub sijhawm, kev lees paub yuav ua rau muaj txiaj ntsig. Thiab yog hais tias koj nyob rau hauv ib txoj kev koom nyob rau hauv no xyiv fab kev ua koob tsheej ntawm gluttony uas mus rau tam sim no, koj muaj ntshav ntawm koj txhais tes. Tag nrho nres." Ntxiv dua thiab, leej twg yog qhov muaj "kev ua koob tsheej zoo siab ntawm kev lom zem?" Puas muaj cov kws paub txog kev rog rog tiag tiag hais tias, "Yaj, gluttony?" Maher hu ua Ted Kyle, RPh, MBA, tus tsim ntawm Conscience Health, "Fat activist." Tab sis kev tawm tswv yim tawm tsam qhov hnyav-raws li thiab lub cev loj-raws li kev tsis ncaj ncees thiab kev ntxub ntxaug tsis yog "tus neeg rog rog," uas zoo li ib tus neeg tau thawb rau qhov kev txaus siab ntawm cov ntaub so ntswg adipose. Ntawm no Kyle piav qhia rau tus American Journal of Managed Care (AJMC) Yuav ua li cas stigma hinders kom raug kev kho mob ntawm rog:

Tej zaum lwm zaus Maher tuaj yeem coj Kyle ntawm nws qhov yeeb yam kom txhua tus tuaj yeem hnov ​​​​txog Kyle nws tau hais li cas?

Maher cov lus tsis txaus siab suav nrog cov lus hauv qab no ib yam nkaus: "Nike, Sports Illustrated, Victoria's Secret, cov tuam txhab uas tshwj xeeb txog kev tawm dag zog txawm li cas los xij txhawb cov neeg uas tsis muaj zog." OK, lub tuam txhab qoj yuav tsis yog thawj qhov uas koj xav txog thaum koj hais txog Victoria's Secret. Ntau ntawm lawv cov lingerie tej zaum tsis tsim tshwj xeeb rau cov chav kawm spinning lossis 100 meter hurdles. Ntxiv mus, hauv nqe lus ntawd, Maher tau ua raws nraim li cov neeg tawm tsam kev tawm tsam tau ceeb toom tawm tsam kev ua: piv txwv tias ib tus neeg ntawm lub cev loj yog "tsis ncaj ncees." Tej zaum Maher yuav tsum mus ntsib qee tus NFL linemen thiab qhia lawv rau lawv lub ntsej muag tias lawv tsis meej pem hauv kev qoj ib ce vim tias lawv dhau ntawm lub cev hnyav.

Thoob plaws hauv nws qhov kev tawm tsam, Maher txuas ntxiv mus ua qhov kev xav ntawm cov neeg uas tuaj yeem muaj lub cev loj dua lossis siab dua lub cev qhov ntsuas (BMI), uas ua rau muaj kev npau taws ntawm cov neeg hauv social media xws li:

Nyob ze ntawm qhov kawg ntawm Maher txoj kev hais lus, Maher tau ua zoo li nws twb paub yuav ua li cas los daws cov kab mob rog rog thiab nws tsuas yog ib qho teeb meem ntawm kev qhia tib neeg kom tsis txhob noj ntau dua. Txoj kev no oversimplifies kev rog rog thiab overlooks ntau ntawm kev tshawb fawb uas tau qhia ntau yam lwm yam uas yuav ua rau muaj kev rog rog. Raws li kuv tau sau ua ntej ntau zaus rau Forbes, lub World Cancer Research Fund (WCRF) International, Thiab Kev Ntsuas Khoom Noj, kev rog rog yog ib qho teeb meem hauv lub cev thiab tsis yog ib qho uas tuaj yeem daws tau nrog cov kev daws teeb meem yooj yim ntawm tsuas yog qhia txhua tus kom noj tsawg dua thiab tawm dag zog ntxiv. Qhov ntawd tau sim hauv 1990's thiab 200o's, thiab dua xyoo 2010's. Txhawm rau tsuas yog liam rau tib neeg tsis quav ntsej qhov tseeb tias ntau hauv peb lub neej tau hloov pauv txij li xyoo 1980's thaum cov neeg rog rog pib nce ntxiv xws li peb cov khoom noj muaj ntau thiab ntau cov khoom noj uas muaj ntau thiab ntau ntxiv. Qee tus hauv Twitter xav nrov nrov (vim tias koj tsis tuaj yeem xav ntsiag to hauv Twitter) vim li cas Maher tsis tau hais ntxiv txog kev lag luam zaub mov zoo li cov hauv qab no:

Cov khoom noj muaj pes tsawg leeg tuaj yeem ua lub luag haujlwm tseem ceeb. Tab sis tej zaum nws tsis yog tus neeg ua txhaum nkaus xwb. Txhua lub sij hawm muaj teeb meem kev noj qab haus huv tseem ceeb rau pej xeem txuas ntxiv mus, muaj cov txheej txheem sib txawv. Nyob rau hauv ob peb lub xyoo dhau los uas tau sib raug mus rau qhov nce ntxiv ntawm kev rog rog, muaj lwm yam kev hloov pauv xws li tib neeg raug cuam tshuam rau txhua yam tshuaj tshiab hauv ib puag ncig, cov nroog thiab cov nroog tsis tshua muaj kev taug kev, thiab kev ua haujlwm tau dhau los ua ntau dua. Tsis tas li ntawd, kev rog rog tau ua rau muaj kev sib kis ntawm lwm yam teeb meem kev noj qab haus huv xws li lwm yam kev mob nkeeg thiab kev kho siab thiab teeb meem kev puas siab puas ntsws uas tau pib hauv xyoo 1980 thiab tau txuas ntxiv mus rau ntau xyoo dhau los. Yog li qhov yuav muaj qee yam ntawm tib yam uas ua rau txhua qhov sib txawv no.

Qhov no yeej tsis yog thawj zaug uas Maher tau hais txog qhov teeb meem kev tshawb fawb tseem tsis tau suav nrog cov kws tshaj lij txuj ci tiag tiag ntawm qhov yeeb yam. Thaum lub sijhawm Covid-19 kis thoob qhov txhia chaw, nws tau thuam cov tshuaj tiv thaiv thiab siv lub ntsej muag lub ntsej muag thaum lub sijhawm tham txog kev siv ivermectin rau Covid-19. Ib tus Twitterer tau taw qhia ntau npaum li cas Maher tau hais ntawm nws qhov yeeb yam tsis ntev los no yog qhov txaj muag me ntsis:

Maher tau hais txog ib yam: "kev cuam tshuam kev cuam tshuam tshwm sim hauv Asmeskas niaj hnub no nrog kev sau ntawv tshiab kom haum rau kev xav lossis tsuas yog ua kom haum qhov koj xav kom muaj tseeb." Puas yog ib qho piv txwv ntawm cov qauv zoo li no yog ib qho kev sib tham uas tus tswv tsev tham txog lub ncauj lus tshawb fawb tab sis tsis tshua coj cov kws tshaj lij tshawb fawb los tham txog lub ntsiab lus?