Amazon's 'Paper Girls' yog lwm qhov kev hloov pauv txawv txawv, zoo li 'Y: Tus txiv neej kawg'

Kuv tsis paub meej tias nws yog dab tsi, tab sis zoo li muaj qee yam hais txog Brian K. Vaughn dab neeg uas ua haujlwm zoo heev hauv daim duab comic, tab sis tsuas yog tsis tuaj yeem ua rau dhia mus rau qhov loj screen adaptations coherently. Peb tau pom qhov no tsis ntev los no nrog Y: Tus Txiv Neej Kawg ntawm FX, uas zoo li nws yuav tsum tau ua ib qho kev hloov pauv, muab qhov kev nyiam ntawm tus thawj comic yog li cas, thiab tseem nws yog qhov phem heev thiab tsis zoo thiab raug tso tseg sai sai.

Tam sim no, tib yam yog qhov tseeb rau Paper Girls, lwm phau ntawv Brian K. Vaughn uas tau txais tau zoo txij li thaum nws tso tawm, tab sis qhov kev hloov pauv ntawm qhov screen, tam sim no ntawm Amazon, tsuas yog ... tsis zoo heev.

Tsis zoo li Saga thiab Y, Kuv muaj tsis nyeem cov ntawv Thawj Cov Ntxhais, yog li kuv tsis muaj qhov tseem ceeb los piv cov yeeb yam no nrog qhov tsis zoo, muaj peev xwm. Kuv tsuas tsis nyiam qhov yeeb yam tag nrho ntawm nws tus kheej. Kuv tau npaj siab tso tseg tom qab ob ntawm yim ntu, tab sis kuv nias rau vim kuv paub tias kuv tsis tuaj yeem txiav txim siab zaum kawg kom txog thaum kuv pom lawv tag nrho. Tab sis thaum kuv mus txog qhov kawg, kuv tseem tsis nyiam nws, thiab kuv xav tias qhov yeeb yam no puas tuaj yeem khaws rau lub caij thib ob, lossis yog tias nws yuav raug tso tseg thiab yuam cov neeg saib kom khaws cov comics rau kev daws teeb meem. Ua siab ncaj, qhov ntawd yuav yog lub tswv yim zoo dua.

Ib yam dab tsi txog Paper Girls tsuas yog… tawm. Kuv tsis tuaj yeem chalk qhov no mus txog qhov "qhov no tsis yog rau koj, tus txiv neej laus" qhov xwm txheej, raws li kuv tuaj yeem sau npe rau ntau qhov kev ua yeeb yam ua yeeb yam nrog cov ntxhais hluas Kuv xav tias zoo heev, los ntawm Disney's Ms. Marvel mus rau Netflix's Tsis Muaj Kuv Puas Muaj rau HBO's Lub Neej Kev Sib Deev ntawm Cov Ntxhais Kawm Qib Siab. Kuv tseem nyiam tso tseg Amazon cov tub ntxhais hluas series The Wilds thiab Panic ntau dua qhov no.

Kev sau ntawv, pacing, lub ntiaj teb no tsuas yog tsis ua haujlwm. Cov yeeb yam yog plodding thiab boring, nrog ntau zaum nyob ib ncig ntawm tos lub sij hawm rifts qhib, sib tov "los ntawm hnub nyoog" dab neeg (thawj lub sij hawm, ib tug hluas nkauj paub tias nws yog gay) nrog loj mecha robots thiab pterodactyls. Ib zaug ntxiv, txawm tias kuv paub tseeb tias tag nrho cov no yog nyob rau hauv cov khoom siv, kom meej meej nws yuav tsum ua haujlwm zoo dua li qhov nws ua ntawm no, vim qhov no zoo li plaub qhov sib txawv qhia tau sib xyaw ua ke hauv txoj hauv kev uas tsis haum.

Muaj qee cov lus nug nthuav tawm hauv no, zoo li koj yuav ua li cas rau lub neej yav tom ntej uas koj pom tias koj tuag los ntawm mob qog noj ntshav xyoo dhau los, tab sis thaum kawg, nws nyuaj dhau los nqis peev rau cov cim no vim tias tsis muaj qhov tseeb. cov ceg txheem ntseeg koom nrog, thiab "txoj cai" ntawm qhov peb pom ntawm no yeej tsis qhia meej. Cov dab neeg mus ncig ua si tsuas yog ua haujlwm thaum koj teeb tsa cov cai raws li daim ntawv no ntawm lub sijhawm mus ncig ua haujlwm, tab sis cov yeeb yam tsis txawm thab sim los teb cov lus nug yooj yim xws li "vim li cas kuv lub neej yav tom ntej tsis nco qab ntsib lawv tus kheej" tsa cov lus nug txog kev faib sijhawm. los yog parallel universes cov yeeb yam tsis sim teb nyob rau hauv tej lub ntsiab lus muaj peev xwm.

Qhov no tsis ua haujlwm raws li kev tshawb fawb nthuav dav ntawm lub sijhawm mus ncig, vim tias muaj kev sib tw ntau dhau ntawm qhov ntawd, thiab Paper Girls tsis ua txhua yam tshwj xeeb ntawm no. Thiab nws tsis ua haujlwm tiag tiag li zaj dab neeg uas muaj hnub nyoog dhau los vim tias nws yuav tsum tau muab sijhawm ntau dhau nrog lub sijhawm ua tsov rog tsis muaj tseeb. Nws tsis haum ua ke, thiab zoo li tsis muaj peev xwm rov tsim dua txhua yam khawv koob tshwm sim los ua cov cim thiab zaj dab neeg no ua haujlwm ntawm nplooj ntawv, zoo ib yam li Y: Tus Txiv Neej Kawg tsuas yog tsis tau txhais ua ib zaj yeeb yaj kiab vim tias tseem tshuav qee yam ntawm ib qho. paub tsis meej txog hnub no.

Kuv tsis tuaj yeem pom zoo rau qhov yeeb yam no. Muaj ntau lub sijhawm mus ncig ua si zoo dua. Muaj cov yeeb yam hluas zoo dua. Thiab ob qhov sib xyaw ua ke ntawm no yog qhov zoo tshaj plaws kev paub ntawm nplooj ntawv, tsis yog qhov screen, zoo li. Txawm hais tias nws tau txais lub caij thib ob, kuv tsis tuaj yeem hais tias kuv yuav txaus siab saib nws.

Ua raws li kuv rau Twitter, YouTube, Facebook thiab Instagram. Sau npe yuav ua rau kuv cov ntsiab lus pub dawb txhua lub hlis puag ncig-tsab ntawv xov xwm, Vajtswv Yob.

Mus nqa kuv cov ntawv sau dab neeg sci-fi Herokiller koob thiab Lub Nees Nruab Nrab Trilogy.

Tau qhov twg los: https://www.forbes.com/sites/paultassi/2022/08/02/amazons-paper-girls-is-another-strange-adaptation-failure-like-y-the-last-man/