John Woods, CTO ntawm Algorand Foundation, tau teb rau kev thuam los ntawm Justin Bons ntawm Cyber Capital uas Algorand yog "chaw nruab nrab thiab tso cai." Woods lees txais qee qhov "kev xav tseem ceeb" tab sis tau sib cav tias cov saw tseem tseem muaj kev ywj pheej lossis tsis tso cai.
Whilst kuv pom tseeb tsis pom zoo tias Algorand yog lub hauv paus thiab tso cai - muaj ntau qhov kev thuam ncaj ncees hauv cov xov no. Nws yog ib qho tseem ceeb kom muaj peev xwm xav txog thiab lees txais cov kev xav tseem ceeb!
Ua tsaug rau qhov kev xav Justin.
Qhib qhov kev pab cuam Relay yog ib feem ntawm kuv 2023 strats. https://t.co/RaoxAxR7A5— John Woods (@JohnAlanWoods) Lub kaum hli ntuj 21, 2022
Centralization thiab censorship ntawm Algorand
Bons tau coj mus rau Twitter thaum Lub Kaum Hli 21 los qhuas Algorand rau nws "txiav ntug" thev naus laus zis tab sis tau sib cav tias "cov neeg saib xyuas tau tso cai tuaj yeem censor TX rau ntawm lub siab." Cov xov 25-tweet tau mus rau hauv kev nthuav dav hais tias Algorand yog lub hauv paus blockchain tswj los ntawm Algorand Foundation.
"Txawm hais tias kev pom zoo tau khiav los ntawm "cov kev koom tes," uas tsis tso cai Lub "relay nodes" tau xaiv los ntawm lub hauv paus, ua rau lawv tso cai!"
Raws li Bons, cov relays tuaj yeem ua "tus neeg saib xyuas rau tag nrho lub cev" vim tias lawv yog "tsuas yog lub luag haujlwm rau thaiv kev nthuav tawm."
Hauv ib qho tweet, Bons tau lees paub tias "kev faib tawm tag nrho tsuas yog qee qhov kev hloov pauv me me xwb" rau Algorand. Txawm li cas los xij, nws ntseeg tias lub xeev tam sim no ntawm blockchain, raws li nws tshaj tawm tias "relay nodes" tuaj yeem raug yuam kom ua raws li OFAC cov npe rau txim" ib yam li peb tau pom. Ethereum.
Bons kuj tau tawm tswv yim txog kev thov tias Algorand tau daws qhov teeb meem trilemma ntawm blockchains. Lub trilemma yog ib qho teeb meem uas ua tiav cov theem txaus ntawm kev ruaj ntseg, decentralization, thiab scalability yog ib qho kev txwv ntawm blockchain pleev. Nws qhov kev lees paub yog tias Algorand txoj hauv kev rau trilemma yuav "zoo txaus" tab sis muaj "qee qhov kev txwv loj."
Nws daws nws nrog qee qhov kev txwv loj
Qhov no txhais tau tias nws tseem nyob hauv trilemma tab sis tuaj yeem ua tau zoo txaus
Qhov ntawd yog yog hais tias cov relay nodes puas tau tag nrho decentralized, uas yog cov lus nug loj ntawm no
- Justin Bons (@Justin_Bons) Lub kaum hli ntuj 21, 2022
John Woods cov lus teb
Thaum Woods tsis kam lees Bons 'lub ntsiab lus thesis, Algorand Foundation CTO tau lees paub tias "Nws tseem ceeb heev uas yuav tsum muaj peev xwm txiav txim siab thiab lees txais cov kev xav tseem ceeb!" lees txais qee qhov kev ua tsis tiav tam sim no ntawm cov saw hlau.
Woods kuj tau rov hais dua cov lus teb los ntawm Patrick Bennett, CEO ntawm TxnLabs, uas tau sib cav tias "kom censor, ALL relays yuav tsum tau censor ... 4 random relays kuv node tshwm sim los tham rau ntawm * qhov * taw tes yuav tsum tau censor." Bennett tau sib cav hais tias "feem ntau ntawm relay nodes" tsis yog ib txoj hauj lwm yooj yim kom ua tiav, muab qhov randomness ua rau hauv lub relay system.
Tsis tas li ntawd, Woods tau lees paub tias qhib qhov kev pab cuam relay yuav yog "qhov tseem ceeb rau 2023" hauv kev nkag mus me me ntawm cov kev txwv ntawm cov kaw lus kaw tam sim no. Ntoo thiab Hais qhov yuav tsum tau "ua kom qhib tau ntau dua," pom zoo tias qhov teeb meem yog "tsis tseem ceeb."
Relays yog equiv rau network keyboards, tab sis nodes lus xaiv rau 4 random relays. Txhawm rau censor, TAG NRHO relays yuav tsum tau censor lossis tsawg kawg rau kuv, 4 random relays kuv cov node tshwm sim los tham rau ntawm * qhov * taw tes yuav tsum tau censor. Yog li 'feem ntau ntawm relay nodes' yog qhov tseem ceeb ntawm no.
— patrick.algo (@patrickbennett) ib Lub kaum hli ntuj 21, 2022
Zuag qhia tag nrho, Bons 'kev thuam yog ua raws li kev txaus siab ntawm Algoran blockchain raws li nws tau hais tias cov yam ntxwv xws li "ALGOs on-chain tswj hwm ... zoo heev." Kev sib tham ntawm Bons thiab Woods hauv xov kuj tau nthuav tawm lub peev xwm rau kev sib tham tiag tiag thiab kev vam meej tshwm sim ntawm Crypto Twitter ib ntus.
Thaum lub sij hawm sib tham tau zoo heev nyob rau hauv lub sij hawm, nws yog fascinating kom pom xws li theem siab kev sib tham txog kev txhim kho technology nrog ib tug ua lag luam cap ntawm ntau tshaj $ 2 billion raug tham li qhib rau pej xeem. Tsis tas li ntawd, kev sib tham nrog pej xeem nrog cov ntsiab lus qhia txog kev txawj ntse ntawm lub zej zog web3 tag nrho.
Tau qhov twg los: https://cryptoslate.com/algorand-cto-responds-to-criticisms-of-centralization-and-permissioned-nature-of-blockchain/